How to Get to Padangbai on 12,000 Rupiah a Day

“Twenty thousand.”

“Eight thousand.”

“Twenty thousand!”



I shrugged. The driver of the bemo – the local Balinese form of public transport, a minibus with the interior stripped bare like a suburban rapist’s van – had pulled over to the side of the road on a busy street in Ubud and parked to increase his bargaining leverage.

“Ok, ok: FIFTEEN!”

“But the price, in fact, is eight.” He spat and then crawled from the driver’s seat.

I was on my way to the beach town of Padangbai via Gianyar, two 8000 rupiah bemo rides totaling perhaps 60 minutes, but had been waylaid just 100 meters into the journey. “Listen,” I said, “you’re GOING to Gianyar – you told me that 30 seconds ago. I give you 8000 rupiah, ya? Real price.”

No, I stop here for sleeping, really!” He mimed someone luxuriantly napping. “Not going Gianyar. No. You get out here.”

“Whatever,” I said, “I’m staying.”

He stood in the sun by the roadside, shuffling his feet and picking at the leaves of an overhanging tree, scowling and clearly agitated. From time to time he made elaborate futile gesticulations at potential passengers, like a 3rd-base coach flashing steal signs.

It is a curious bit of psychology that a person living on perhaps $10 a day will refuse one of those dollars because he would rather have two in its place, but here in Bali, that was not just a possibility, but a governing principle. In a solid calendar month in Indonesia, I had never once been quoted the proper price for a journey by a public bus operator, and I mean this sincerely: not even a single time. The going rate was usually double, but sometimes triple or more, and operated under a dual aegis – that of perceived ignorance on the one hand (“Well, I guess it could be 30,000…”) and of tired resignation on the other (“Jesus, just pay him the extra dollar!”). Today, however, having eaten well and having double-checked the correct fare (and having been consistently scammed by nearly everyone for fully 30 days) I was in no hurry.

The driver sweltered in the sun for perhaps 25 more minutes, his face beaded with sweat, before climbing back into the driver’s seat and starting off along the road to Gianyar, where, arriving, he grudgingly accepted the 8000 rupiah and pointed me towards the street on which the second bemo to Padangbai would stop. I clambered aboard that bemo not 10 minutes later, quickly winding thru the town of Klungkung and onto the coast highway, which was the point at which things turned suddenly ugly.

Please understand, I’ve never been one of those travellers obsessed with getting the ‘local price’. In towns with an established two-tier pricing system (I’m thinking the boats on Lago de Atitlan in Guatemala), or at attractions with a special ‘foreigner entrance ticket’, I’ve happily paid the extra charge, knowing that the community as a whole has agreed on this system; and for quantities like lodging or taxi rides I’m more than content to do a bit of haggling, knowing that it’s just a part of that business.

In Bali, though, it was simply greed. The price of necessities like bottled drinking water were quoted at outrageous levels and then tediously bargained down, and public bus operators (a field sacrosanct even in rapacious India) considered what they thought the market would bear, and then optimistically added 100%.

This is why, when the bemo’s moneyman shoved my 8000 rupiah back towards me and demanded double, I simply said, ‘no.’

“Fifteen!” he hissed, “Fifteen!”

“But it isn’t. That’s the point.”

“Friend,” a man next to the driver started in, “This is just small money for you, ya? Not so much for you…”

“But that isn’t the point: the price is 8000.”

The moneyman barked at the driver, who pulled the bus to the side of the road.

“We take you to police, ya?”

“Sure. Police. Great.”

The man next to the driver was cooing, “Friend, 8000 is not so much, just a dollar, you have small money…”

“You did not hear me. The point is that you are dishonest. Anda tidak jujur, yes? You. Are. Dishonest.”

At the side of the road, a sign read, PADANGBAI 7KM.

“We go police!” the moneyman howled.

“Go then.”

The bus did not move. I grabbed my bag and headed out the door, into the blinding sunlight of the coast highway.

I walked two of those seven kilometers, then, my sandals scuffing through the grass at roadside as other buses or bemos or taxis would stop from time to time, quoting a ludicrous price in the hundreds of thousands for the seven minute journey down the coast road. It made me more determined to walk.

Finally, a man in a dirty lemon-yellow van drove up. He rolled alongside me for a hundred yards or more, talking out the window, prices falling further and further from the heights.

“Four, he said, finally, “Four.”

I blinked at him through the sunlight and then climbed in.

“That sounds like an honest answer.”

It’s difficult to know what to make of such an incident; in what scale do we judge it, and not see its dimensions totally deranged? Am I some itinerant Walter Sobchek (“It’s about drawing a line in the sand, Dude!”), abusing an impoverished local people with his inflated sense of righteousness, or are the mendacious public bus-men of greater Bali just an evil, reverse-exploiting horde? Should I have done what most do and just give in to the demands, or am I some kind of shining knight standing up for travelers everywhere? Could it be that bemo drivers are really Robin-Hoods, taking the wealth of the unworthy and giving it to those in greater need? Are members of a developing-world society entitled to overcharge the comparatively rich who visit them? And are those visitors likewise entitled to refuse, even at the cost of significant inconvenience?

Today was one of those days in travel where difficulty comes without any easy answer.


7 thoughts on “How to Get to Padangbai on 12,000 Rupiah a Day

  1. Personally, I see why they hike up their prices for foreigners but, that said, when they encounter someone who is both a) hip to their scam and b) determined not to capitulate, then I think they should probably just let it go and charge you the correct fare. You’ve pretty much shown them that you’re not an easy mark so why do they feel entitled to continue to try and shake you down even when it has been established by both parties that that is in fact what is happening? Sure, people have a capacity for being sneaky but carrying on like they’re entitled to brazenly cheat you is not cool.

  2. I am proud of your determination – and willingness to inconvenience yourself for principal. I know I would have just paid because a walk in the heat would not have been for me!

  3. So, Matt, here is another dilemma for you: when in Cambodia, a small child of six or seven came up to me begging for money. I knew if I gave him money, it would only perpetuate the scam, as he was part of a stereotypical stable of beggars, similar to those in Slumdog or Oliver Twist. I realized if I didn’t give him money, he would be beaten for not achieving his goal. So I deeply conflicted. He kept after me for several blocks, even going so far as to grab onto my leg, crying hysterically. I decided to take a stand, so I didn’t give in and give him money. To this day I doubt my response. I still wonder how badly he was beaten for my resistance.

  4. I find this funny because this story is EXACTLY my story when we were trying to get from Ubud to Padangbai. Word to word. The driver was trying to charge us 20 when we were told it should only be about 8. The haggling went back and forth until we settled on 12. Glad i was not the only person who went through this.

  5. Hands down one of the most academically examined and well written pieces on the duopoly of third-world travel that I have seen in a long time. I absolutely agree, the price is the price. I will happily pay US$1 more, but when you triple the price, the conversation shifts to principle.

  6. This reminds me of my experience in Marrakesh – and not in a good way. While as a traveler you will seldom pay local prices, to be charged 300% times what the price actually is cannot be right, and it is a matter of principle.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s